Let's all do the al chet (1)

[A slight variant of this page appears here 10 times. In each the text remains essentially the same. However, I will add a link to a new “survey” each time.]

I have written elsewhere, that I came to the rabbinate out of “polity” not “piety“. My involvement was as a community organizer.

Nonetheless, I recall sitting one Yom Kippur day in the late 1960s with a number of friends who had formed a group called Or Hadash (New Light). There we were on a blanket in the heat of the day, somewhere beyond the end of Alta Drive or Fair Oaks Ave. in Angeles National Forest above Altadena, California. We read the Al Chet to each other. (I sent the papers I had that related to this group to the American Jewish Archives in 2007.) We actually framed that experience as both polity and piety. We felt that by talking with each other how we had hardened our hearts we were both fulfilling the pious “obligation” to recite our people’s text and at the same time building a stronger more cohesive group.

ten times al chet

The Al Chet, an alphabetical acrostic, is recited as many as ten times throughout Yom Kippur. If we include its recitation on Selichot (the last Shabbat before Rosh haShannah), that is even more. Perhaps we can approach this list in a different way. How can we read these lines in a manner so that they retain their newness and urgency?

all twenty-two

  • א We have erred against You by אמוץ הלב hardening our hearts.
  • ב We have erred against You by בטוי שׂפתים speaking perversely.
  • ג We have erred against You גלוי ובסתר publicly and privately.
  • ד We have erred against You by דבור פה corrupt speech.
  • ה We have erred against You by הרהור הלב evil thought.
  • ו We have erred against You by ודוי פה insincere confession.
  • ז We have erred against You זדון ובשׁגגה intentionally and unintentionally.
  • ח We have erred against You by חלול השׁם desecrating your name.
  • ט We have erred against You by טפשׁות פה foolish talk.
  • י We have erred against You יודעים ובלא יודעים knowingly and unknowingly.
  • כ We have erred against You by כפת שׁחד bribery.
  • ל We have erred against You by לשׁון הרע slander.
  • מ We have erred against You in מאכל ובמשׁתה eating and drinking.
  • נ We have erred against You by נטית גרון false pride.
  • We have erred against You by שׂקור עין wanton glances.
  • ע We have erred against You by עזות מצח effrontery.
  • פ We have erred against You by פלילות perverting justice.
  • צ We have erred against You by צרות עין envy.
  • ק We have erred against You by קשׁיות ערף being stubborn.
  • ר We have erred against You by רכילות tale bearing.
  • We have erred against You by שׂנאת חנם causeless hatred.
  • ת We have erred against You by תמהון לבב confusion of values.

In the day of R. Ila’i, the entire concept of reciting such a list was fresh, new and challenging. As others learned about his practice, it is possible that what at first may have been a free association became more formal. It is not uncommon for what begins as “description” to develop into “prescription”. (“I was with R. Ila’i at Yom Kippur last year and he did….“) What might happen in our congregations if we scrapped the liturgical reading of these lines and discussed their content instead?

al chet chart

al chet chart

how many different ways can we approach the al chet so that it retains its relevance?

I have used the tools of the Web (in particular SurveyMonkey) to develop a number of questionnaires that may help us focus our attention on different aspects of the al chet. I’ll add a link to each one on a different day. Feel free to take the “survey” and share the link with others. As of this posting there are ten different surveys. If you can think of another one, please add your thoughts in the comments.

1.
who participates in this kind of behavior, and how often?

Click here to enter your responses.

Respond to each statement (there are 22 of them, one for each Hebrew letter) by selecting with whom (at which level of communal living) you have experienced and/or participated in this error and at what frequency.

We may be able to rank these (as to seriousness) later.

This version, illustrated above, is available as a downloadable PDF.


2.

rank the errors from most egregious to the least egregious


3.

“this error was a particular problem for me when I was…”

If a particular category does not match your life, feel free to ignore it.
(If at some later time it does, I expect to keep this online… as long as these phenomena can remain online. If you can think of better categories for the column headers, please let me know.)


4.

how do I feel when I experience a particular chet happening?

Do I respond with anger, sorrow, or am I apathetic?


5.
rank all 22 errors in terms of which is the hardest (for me) to avoid

Is it eating and drinking or perhaps false pride?


6.

how do I respond when I see an error done?

Do I point out the error or ignore it?


7.

age specific errors

Is a particular behavior a chet at a specific age, but not when done at another age (for example: foolish talk)?


8.

do we perceive some of these errors as more commonly associated with men or women?

You might want to do this with a partner of the opposite sex; then you can compare responses to see where you agree and disagree.


9.

it has been x amount of time since I have seen a particular error done

Either I live in a rarified world, or I may not be paying attention.


10.

rank all 22 errors in order of most commonly done to least

I and my friends may not do this one or that one, but when I look at the larger world I see these as most common and those as least common.


let’s all do the… what?

“Let’s all do the Cherkessia!” was the introductory line of an “Israeli” line dance we learned as children. The only reference to the dance on the Web is on a page that consists of no more than links to three other pages that either no longer exist or no longer contain the information originally promised.

Fake News vs. Truth a case of Goliath vs. David

Is Fake News vs. Truth a case of Goliath vs. David?
Once we knew one truth

Over forty years ago, Rabbi Richard N. Levy wrote a paragraph that entered the Gates of Prayer Siddur. I quoted from it in a sermon during the Clinton impeachment hearings that dealt with “what is truth”.

Once we learned one truth, and […]

Jews and Campaign Buttons: A Time-Honored Tradition

a selection of Jewish-themed campaign buttons 1940-2016

A briefer version of this blog post, with fewer illustrations, was published as “Ten Minutes of Torah” on October 27, 2016 on ReformJudaism.org.

Strangers don’t often interact on New York’s streets. Yet, this election season, I am often stopped and asked about my political lapel button.

Generally, I have found […]

may our cups overflow

Psalm 23:5b

May our efforts in the New Yearoverflow with goodnessand help create a world of wholeness and peace.

 

Linoleum cut produced by Mark, September 2014
The “cup” is brown, “overflow” is in shades of blue.

crossover

through a sea of sound

Shabbat Shirah usually marks the beginning of Jewish Music Month. However, I’ve not seen any reference to it this year. Nonetheless, it is appropriate that this week marks the celebration of a significant anniversary in American Jewish music.

from חזן to opera star

The family in which I grew up was (to put […]

…let's experiment

with minor updates

100!

As Jay writes:

There’s something about round numbers, even if they don’t actually represent anything particularly special.

Were she alive, our mother: Faye [Avrunin] Hurvitz, would be 100 years old today [in 2013]; one day before the winter solstice.

Faye Hurvitz wearing her “I’m a Scientist” button

For someone as modest (about herself) as she, she […]

building tabernacles of peace

May our efforts spread clouds of glory as we build true tabernacles of peace.

וּפְרוֹשׂ עָלֵינוּ סֻכַּת שְׁלוֹמֶךָ

Sifra to Psalm 18:11-12 and Siddur: Ma’ariv: Hashkiveinu

Linoleum cut produced by Mark, Summer 2004.

©Mark Hurvitz2004

this year’s card

the list of cards

#blogelul — hear

women should be seen & heard

wow, and how!

Briefly put. Support Women of the Wall (and the New Israel Fund).

Be sure you can…hearwomen’svoices!

women of the wall members blow the shofar at the back of the western wall plaza during its monthly rosh chodesh service, aug. 7, 2013. (miriam alster)

Here’s a Yeshiva world perspective.

And an appropriate button:

women should be seen […]

#blogelul — believe

i believe

siblinghood

Especially since September 11, 2001, we’ve heard a great deal about the common bonds among the Abrahamic religions. It is a lovely idea, and something worth working towards. However, even a simple glance at one of the most iconic stories of Abraham illustrates how different the three major “Abrahamic” religions are (the fourth is the […]

#blogelul — be

you don't have to be jewish to oppose the war in vietnam

mad man

Ad man William Bernbach developed a number of famous campaigns. For our purpose today, his most important is that for Levy’s bakery.

Correction (January 14, 2014): the woman behind the man!

Judy Portas died Tuesday, January 7, 2014 at the age of 91. As the story in the New York Times reports:

As Ms. Protas, a retired […]